hello
Moderator: Bob
-
sweetmidori
- Tourist
- Posts: 1
- Joined: Mon Nov 01, 2004 10:27 pm
hello
I have a sound recording studio, and I played around with the levels, untill the backround noise was eliminated almost completely. I can say with confidence that Bob says "Promise me you won't give up that easy. On the flight back, you tell the truth, okay?"
-
A guy
Greetings new member!
Yea we've heard everything and we still dont want to know.
Its like the Zapruder film. No one will ever really know what happened.
Its like the Zapruder film. No one will ever really know what happened.
I know this topic has been hashed to death here and on other message boards. But I seemed to detect sarcasm towards Sweetmidori. Maybe he/she was so happy with their discovery that they felt the need to share with other LiT fans. That's ok, even though we all have our own opinions as to Bob's final words.
I am going through some difficult times on behalf of my children and cliques at school. I felt the need to step in and say something in a newbie's defense.
Now, how'bout a group hug?
I am going through some difficult times on behalf of my children and cliques at school. I felt the need to step in and say something in a newbie's defense.
Now, how'bout a group hug?
-
lostinflorida
- Traveler
- Posts: 6
- Joined: Wed Oct 27, 2004 5:46 pm
- Location: Florida
- Contact:
just one LAST thing before no one ever talks about this again (b/c really its been argued about for sooo long) In the original screenplay there is a "rough" scripting of what happens.
In the original screenplay, this scene isn't even close to how it turns out! Here is how it is in sofia's original screenplay:
"
BOB
Charlotte!
But she can't hear him over the loudspeaker. He rushes to her.
C.U. she turns and we see she is crying.
The music swells. He embraces her, holding her close to him in the crowd.
BOB (CONT'D)
Why are you crying?
CHARLOTTE (sincere)
I'll miss you.
He kisses her, hugs her good-bye.
BOB
I know, I'm going to miss you, too.
He holds her close.
Charlotte watches Bob as he reaches his car, he turns and looks at her.
She smiles at him, and is lost in the crowd.
Bob gets into his car.
CUT TO:
Charlotte walks with the crowd as they go on their way.
CUT TO:
INT. CAR - DAY
Back in the Presidential, alone, Bob leans against the little doily. They drive off.
He looks out the window, Bob's happy he's going home, he's happy he came to Tokyo.
Bob's P.O.V.- Tokyo goes past his window
FADE TO BLACK. "
****
Again, that's how it is in Sofia's original screenplay, if you are interested.
One last thing: I also have heard it with the background noise almost silent. I'm almost certain that Bob says,
"Promise me you won't give up that easy. On the flight home, tell him the truth, ok?"
each time i rewatch the movie, when this scene happens I don't pretend that Bob is saying this into Charlotte's ear. Rather, I imagine that I don't know what is being said; i don't want to know what he said, and in a way i regret ever listening to it with the background sound down. It's sooo much better if you dont' know what he said. it's more magical (for a lack of a better term) that way...
And with that, let us never speak of this whisper again...let it simply be remembered as a last private goodbye between two intimate friends, just as Sofia had intended it to be....
In the original screenplay, this scene isn't even close to how it turns out! Here is how it is in sofia's original screenplay:
"
BOB
Charlotte!
But she can't hear him over the loudspeaker. He rushes to her.
C.U. she turns and we see she is crying.
The music swells. He embraces her, holding her close to him in the crowd.
BOB (CONT'D)
Why are you crying?
CHARLOTTE (sincere)
I'll miss you.
He kisses her, hugs her good-bye.
BOB
I know, I'm going to miss you, too.
He holds her close.
Charlotte watches Bob as he reaches his car, he turns and looks at her.
She smiles at him, and is lost in the crowd.
Bob gets into his car.
CUT TO:
Charlotte walks with the crowd as they go on their way.
CUT TO:
INT. CAR - DAY
Back in the Presidential, alone, Bob leans against the little doily. They drive off.
He looks out the window, Bob's happy he's going home, he's happy he came to Tokyo.
Bob's P.O.V.- Tokyo goes past his window
FADE TO BLACK. "
****
Again, that's how it is in Sofia's original screenplay, if you are interested.
One last thing: I also have heard it with the background noise almost silent. I'm almost certain that Bob says,
"Promise me you won't give up that easy. On the flight home, tell him the truth, ok?"
each time i rewatch the movie, when this scene happens I don't pretend that Bob is saying this into Charlotte's ear. Rather, I imagine that I don't know what is being said; i don't want to know what he said, and in a way i regret ever listening to it with the background sound down. It's sooo much better if you dont' know what he said. it's more magical (for a lack of a better term) that way...
And with that, let us never speak of this whisper again...let it simply be remembered as a last private goodbye between two intimate friends, just as Sofia had intended it to be....
